Do You Have the Right Financial People on Your Team?

fractional-cfo

John Nieuwenburg

John Nieuwenburg has been a professional business coach since 2004. Prior to becoming a coach, he held executive positions with Tip Top Tailors and BC Liquor Stores. In 2019, MacKay CEO Forums awarded him with Canada’s CEO Trusted Advisor Award in the Small Business category. Since becoming a coach, John has worked with over 350 clients, taking them through a systematic process that helps them feel organized, confident and in control of their businesses.

Think about this: would you drive a car without a dashboard?

Without a gas gauge?

Without a speedometer?

Of course not.

Yet many business owners are effectively doing exactly that when it comes to their financials. They’re running a company with no reliable dashboard—and no one to tell them what the numbers mean.

Part of the challenge is that most small businesses are poorly served by the traditional accounting profession. I’m not here to bash accountants. They play an important role: bookkeeping, taxes, and producing formal financial reports.

But here’s the truth many owners don’t realize:

The accounting profession is not built to deliver everything a small business owner needs to succeed.

They are there to give you accurate numbers. Not to run your financial system, and not to interpret your financial picture in a way that helps you make better decisions.

Large companies know this.

That’s why they have bookkeepers, accountants, controllers, and CFOs—four different roles working together to create clarity, accuracy, and strategy.

Small businesses almost never have all four. Most have one (or maybe two)…and that’s why they’re flying blind.

The Financial Maturity Ladder

Below is the financial maturity ladder, in simple language, along with guidance on when each role becomes necessary.

1. The Bookkeeper — Records the Data

Focus: the past
Purpose: keep the financial engine up to date

Bookkeepers categorize expenses, reconcile accounts, handle payroll posting, organize receipts, and generate basic reports. They make sure the “raw data” is captured and complete.

What they don’t do: explain the numbers, spot trends, or guide your decisions.

If your bookkeeping is sloppy or out of date, everything else downstream becomes unreliable.

When you need one:

  • As soon as admin is piling up.
  • When you’re doing the books yourself at night and weekends.
  • When accuracy becomes inconsistent or delayed.

2. The Accountant — Keeps You Compliant

Focus: the past
Purpose: year-end reporting and tax compliance

Accountants file corporate taxes, make year-end adjusting entries, and provide official statements.

What they don’t do: Run the financial side of your business, interpret performance, or help you plan for the future. They are historians, not co-pilots.

When you need one:

  • Always. Compliance is not optional.
  • But don’t confuse “I have an accountant” with “I understand my numbers.”

3. The Controller — Makes the Numbers Accurate, Timely, and Useful

Focus: the present
Purpose: turn raw data into reliable information

This is the role almost every growing business is missing.

Controllers ensure your bookkeeping is correct and disciplined. They run month-end close, implement controls, oversee job costing and reporting, and make sure financial information is trustworthy and delivered on time.

If the bookkeeper captures the data, the controller turns it into something you can use.

What they don’t do: long-range forecasting or strategic financial planning.

When you need one:

  • When your numbers are always late.
  • When you don’t trust the accuracy of your reports.
  • When cash flow surprises keep happening.

4. The CFO — Turns Information Into Strategy

Focus: the future
Purpose: guide decisions and map the road ahead

This is where the real business value is created.

A CFO takes reliable financial information (created by the first three roles) and interprets it from a business owner’s perspective. They help you understand margins, pricing, profitability, cash flow, and the financial implications of every decision.

CFOs handle forecasting, scenario planning, financing decisions, and growth strategy.

Important: a CFO cannot be effective if the underlying data is messy or late. Strategy depends on clean inputs.

When you need one:

  • When revenue reaches roughly $1–2M/year and decisions start carrying real financial risk.
  • When you feel like you’re guessing instead of planning.
  • When you’ve outgrown your accountant’s ability to advise you.

The Roles Side by Side

Bookkeeper: What happened?
Accountant: How do we report it?
Controller: Can we trust the numbers?
CFO: What should we do next?

Once you see this layout, it becomes clear why so many owners feel in over their heads.

They assume their accountant’s year-end statements are telling them everything they need to know. They aren’t. They can’t.

And this misunderstanding has put many owners into trouble—sometimes quickly.

Why a Fractional CFO Is Often the Missing Link

Most small businesses cannot afford a full-time CFO. But a fractional CFO gives you the benefit of that strategic lens—at a fraction of the cost.

A good fractional CFO sees the numbers in context: your cash realities, your goals, your pricing, your operational constraints, your team, your market.

They help you make better decisions, anticipate problems, and steer the financial side of the business with clarity instead of guesswork.

For most businesses, the CFO is the first real “financial strategist” they’ve ever had.

And by the time you reach $1–2M in revenue, that strategy becomes a must-have, not a luxury.

Which Role Do You Need Next?

You likely need:

  • A bookkeeper if admin is piling up or your books are behind.
  • A controller if your reports are late or you don’t trust your numbers.
  • A CFO if you have clean numbers but no forward-looking clarity.
  • An accountant for taxes and compliance (always).

As your business grows and matures, you add the right people at the right time.

Trying to get CFO-level advice from your accountant or bookkeeper is like expecting your mechanic to fly the plane.

They all play important roles—but they’re not interchangeable.

If you’d like help assessing what role your business needs next—and how to build a financial dashboard you can actually trust—I invite you to book a complimentary 15-minute consultation with me.

We’ll get clear on where you are and what you really need so you can stop flying blind and start running your business like the CEO.

Book2

Build a Self-Managing Company

How to build a business that runs smoothly, profitably, and (mostly) without you.

Feeling stressed out and overwhelmed with a business that is taking all your time - and not giving you enough in return?

Are you finding it challenging to hire the right team (and get them to do the right things)?

I wrote this little guide for you!

Enter your details below to receive your free copy!